In a recent landmark ruling, a federal judge in Los Angeles has determined that Mariah Carey is not guilty of stealing from fellow songwriters with her iconic holiday anthem, "All I Want For Christmas Is You." 

On Wednesday, Judge Mónica Ramírez Almadani granted Carey and co-writer Walter Afanasieff summary judgment, effectively dismissing the $20 million lawsuit without the need for a trial. The case was brought forward by songwriters Andy Stone and Troy Powers, who claimed that Carey’s 1994 classic infringed upon their earlier country song of the same name.

Despite their claims of substantial similarities and an "overwhelming likelihood" that Carey had heard their song, the court found no merit in the allegations. Judge Almadani pointed out that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that their works were substantially similar, noting that both songs utilized common Christmas themes that predate their creations.

Additionally, the judge ordered sanctions against Stone and Powers and their legal team for pursuing a frivolous lawsuit, mandating them to cover part of Carey’s legal fees. In a statement, their attorney expressed disappointment and hinted at the possibility of an appeal.

Carey’s holiday hit has seen renewed success in recent years, topping Billboard’s Hot 100 for six consecutive years, solidifying its place as a modern Christmas staple. While Carey and Afanasieff have faced their own disputes regarding song credits, this ruling has temporarily united them against copyright challenges.